Fr. Schall: Mercy begins where justice ends—and it is not a stamp of approval…
(CUSA) – Mercy ends with a final judgment. It is not a blank check or free love. Nor is it a substitute for repentance.
The only thing that goes on forever is divine love, but before we get there we must follow the path of Christ himself. God can forgive anything if we are willing to ask for it. —Ed.
FR. JAMES V. SCHALL, S.J.—
A Holy Year devoted to mercy seems paradoxical in a world filled with persecution, terror, war, and ideology.
In the ancient world, wars resulted in the massacre of all the remaining inhabitants. In the last century, whole peoples were destroyed. When Mosul in Iraq fell a couple of years ago, not only were the Christian and other citizens killed, but their buildings and records were destroyed.
Before such atrocities, the reaction of normal people is one of loathing and, yes, retribution. When such things happen, it is usually a sign of the breakdown of civil defense which, in turn, depends on cultural integrity of a country. No one, however, should desire slaughter just so that he can demonstrate his compassion and mercy for both the victims and for those who carry the destruction out.
“Mercy isn’t just free market loving each other,” says Cardinal Gerhard Mueller, the head of the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. “When God bursts into the life of a man, in the measure of his acceptance, it tends also to change also the way he looks at things, his attitude, the criteria of his actions, and thus, by grace, also his behavior.”
Mercy is designed to uphold and restore the law, not to subvert it or replace it. Mercy, in its own way, affirms the difference between good and evil. It does not eliminate it or make it insignificant. An understanding of mercy that implicitly fosters evil by underestimating its power is not legitimate.
If mercy were granted for whatever we did, but no change of heart or action resulted, it would make no difference what we did. Mercy would cover all our sins. When Christ responded that we should forgive someone seventy times seven times, He had in mind someone who really did need frequent repentance because he was weak or overcome by many troubles.
But Christ might be suspicious of a man’s 491st request for forgiveness when none of the previous 490 (70 x 7) merciful grants were accompanied by any effort to change one’s ways. Mercy is not a blank cheque for doing whatever we want, for “free market love”.
Mercy and justice
Mercy cannot be understood by itself. It must always be seen in the context of justice, of a desire to render back what is due. Mercy begins where justice ends, but it does not deny the centrality of justice.
Like any other virtue, we must first understand what mercy is. “Theology is at the service of doctrine and, in turn, doctrine is at the service of pastoral care, which at the same time helps theology and pastoral care to better specify the object of their attention. It is an uninterrupted circularity of theology, doctrine, and pastoral care in which doctrine has a certain precedence,” Cardinal Mueller explains.
What does this precedence of doctrine mean? Aren’t we supposed to be leery of “rigidity”? Here we recall Chesterton’s observation that the modern world is full of Christian virtues but they are floating about unbalanced by each other. Right order depends on observing the intrinsic limits as of what each virtue is.
Mercy is a surprisingly difficult virtue to deal with in practice. We frequently hear that God’s mercy is infinite and covers a multitude of sins. It does. But this does not mean that no judgment is involved in the exercise of mercy.
No world is complete in which the limits of virtues are not acknowledged by those who put them into reality. Plato understood this very clearly in the last myth of the Republic when he saw that justice needed to be ultimately upheld lest the world itself be created in injustice.
What does mercy imply? Mercy only exists in a world wherein evil actions happen: a fallen world. We do not speak of mercy when something good happens; we give thanks. Thus, in a world without evil, there is no need for mercy. And while this may be obvious, it can prove complicated.
In a world dominated by relativism, in which no identifiable wrong can happen, mercy is irrelevant. If what I do is my “right”, whatever it may be, I cannot be blamed or punished for it. In this sense, universal mercy risks approving everything, of claiming that nothing is ever evil.
We cannot demand mercy
When does mercy come into view? Logically, it follows these steps: 1) Men are free; mercy has no place in a deterministic world. 2) Freely chosen acts have consequences for good or ill. Some, including the one who performs them, are injured or deceived by our free choices. 3) These wrongful acts are contrary to justice. They require acknowledgement and punishment. Punishment is designed both to uphold what is right and to guide the one who commits the act back to observing standards that are right.
Thus far, we have no place for mercy. Mercy arises only when the one who does something unjust recognizes that his act was the result of his own choice. When he finally understands and admits that he put something wrong into the world, that he is being punished justly, then it is possible to speak of “forgiveness”.
To be merciful does not apply to the sinner, who can only hope to be forgiven. Mercy cannot be demanded. The first step of someone who does evil is to want to accept justice for his wrong, to acknowledge that what was wrong was in fact wrong. Mercy arises from the side of the ones who have suffered from the sins or who must punish them.
Mercy has two levels, a divine side and a human side. From the human side, we are asked to forgive enemies and the acknowledged sins of others. But this willingness to forgive is not a minimization of the wrongs, but a recognition of their seriousness.
Mercy is not a substitute for repentance on the part of the one who does evil. Mercy is rather a gesture on the part of those who suffer from our evil deeds or words. They will allow repentance to take effect in terms of a different way of life, one that avoids sinning.